Best Payroll Companies 2025

Need a payroll provider that handles everything from time tracking to tax filing? We’ve researched and compared the top payroll companies of 2025 so you can find the right fit—explore our breakdown below and compare features, pricing, and more.

Last Updated: October, 2025
9.5
Outstanding


24/7 US-Based Support

9.8
Outstanding


All-in-One Payroll & HR

9.2
Excellent


Unlimited Pay Runs

Our Most Popular

Best SurePayroll Features:

  • Easy Setup – Start in Minutes
  • Accurate Tax Calculations
  • Mobile-Friendly Platform
  • Get 6 Months of Free Payroll
9.8
Outstanding

7954 user reviews on 3 sites

Best Paychex Features: 

  • Used by 750K+ Businesses
  • Automatic Tax Calculations
  • Compliance Expertise for SMB’s
9.5
Outstanding

6431 user reviews on 2 sites

Best Gusto Features:

 

  • All-In-One Payroll
  • For Small-Mid Sized Businesses
  • Transparent Pricing
9.2
Excellent

5974 user reviews on 2 sites

Best OnPay Features:

 

  • Run Unlimited Payroll
  • Simple Transparent Pricing
  • Federal, State & Local Tax Filings
8.8
Very Good

3754 user reviews on 2 sites

Best Paycor Features:

 

  • Automated Routine Tasks
  • Payroll Tax Compliance
  • Trusted by 40K+ Businesses
8.5
Good

2997 user reviews on 2 sites

Best ADP Features:

 

  • Direct Deposits
  • For Businesses of All Sizes
  • Dedicated Customer Support
8.2
Good

2308 user reviews on 2 sites

Editor's Choice for 2025:

Top Pick for Payroll

Best SurePayroll Features:

  • Easy Setup – Start in Minutes
  • Accurate Tax Calculations
  • Mobile-Friendly Platform
  • Get 6 Months of Free Payroll
9.8
Outstanding

7954 user reviews on 3 sites