Compare The Best Payroll Services & Software (2023)

As your business grows, having to deal with Payroll for your employees is a big task. Payroll software is a great way to get started and get things done fast and efficient. Payroll software can help you with time tracking and pay computation to direct deposits and tax filing. All you’ll need to do is choose one that can meet your company's needs. Here are the Top Payroll Picks for 2023:

Last Updated: May, 2025

Compare The Best Payroll Services & Software (2023)

As your business grows, having to deal with Payroll for your employees is a big task. Payroll software is a great way to get started and get things done fast and efficient. Payroll software can help you with time tracking and pay computation to direct deposits and tax filing. All you’ll need to do is choose one that can meet your company's needs. Here are the Top Payroll Picks for 2023:

6 Months FREE
ADP logo
9.8/10
Outstanding

3116 reviews on 2 websites
9.8/10
Outstanding

3116 reviews on 2 websites

ADP Best Features:

  • Trusted by +800,000 Businesses 
  • Robust Payroll Software
  • Great For SMBs
  • Dedicated Customer Support
ADP video

ADP Best Features:

  • 800K Satisfied Customers 
  • Robust Payroll Software
  • Great For SMBs
  • Dedicated Customer Support
Visit Site
  • Time and Attendance
  • HR and Recruiting
  • Calculate Taxes
  • Online Setup
  • 24/7 Support
  • Mobile Friendly
  • Full Scalability
Sure logo
9.5/10
Outstanding

2848 reviews on 3 websites
9.5/10
Outstanding

2848 reviews on 3 websites

SurePayroll Best Features:

  • Run unlimited payrolls – scheduled payments
  • Same-day payroll – immediate payments
  • Multiple pay rates – accurate rates
Sure video

SurePayroll Best Features:

  • Run unlimited payrolls
  • Same day payroll
  • Multiple pay rates
Get Quote
  • Time and Attendance
  • Calculate Taxes
  • Easy SetUp
  • Small business
Paychex logo
9.2/10
Excellent

2165 reviews on 2 websites
9.2/10
Excellent

2165 reviews on 2 websites

Paychex Best Features:

  • Automatic tax calculations & filling
  • Dedicated 24/7 US-based Support 
  • Smooth Employees Onboarding
Paychex video

Paychex Best Features:

  • Employees Onboarding
  • Automatic Tax Calculations 
  • 24/7 US-Based Support
Visit Site
  • Time and Attendance
  • Staff Management
  • HR and Recruiting
  • Calculate Taxes
  • Easy SetUp
  • Mobile Friendly
OnPay logo
8.8/10
Very Good

1739 reviews on 2 websites
8.8/10
Very Good

1739 reviews on 2 websites

OnPay Best Features:

  • Hourly and salaried wages
  • Automated onboarding
  • Free migration and setup
OnPay video

OnPay Best Features:

  • Easy Employee Onboarding
  • Built for SMBs
  • Free Migration and Setup
Visit Site
  • Time and Attendance
  • HR and Recruiting
  • Calculate Taxes
  • Online Setup
Paycor logo
8.5/10
Good

1861 reviews on 2 websites
8.5/10
Good

1861 reviews on 2 websites

Paycor Best Features:

  • Time Clock Software
  • Payroll and tax compliance
  • Reporting and analytics
Paycor video

Paycor Best Features:

  • Payroll & Tax Compliance
  • HR Software Included
  • Reporting and Analytics
Visit Site
  • Time and Attendance
  • Staff Management
  • HR and Recruiting
  • Bonus Payrolls
Gusto logo
9.0/10
Very Good

2589 reviews on 2 websites
9.0/10
Very Good

2589 reviews on 2 websites

Gusto Best Features:

  • The All-In-One Platform for Payroll, Benefits
  • Autopilot Payroll Feature
  • Best Value For SMBs
  • Simple & User-friendly Interface
Gusto video

Gusto Best Features:

  • Holistic Payroll Solution
  • Simple & User-friendly
  • Best Value For SMBs
Visit Site
  • Time and Attendance
  • Staff Management
  • HR and Recruiting
  • Calculate Taxes
  • Easy SetUp
  • Mobile Friendly

Want your business to be reviewed on our site?

Apply now

Gusto: Simplifying The Payroll Process For SMBs, And Beyond

Did you know that small business owners spend an estimated five hours per pay run on facilitating payroll activities? This adds up to a staggering 21 days annually – which could have been significantly reduced when the correct platform was chosen to facilitate these actions. Payroll usually includes costs such as salaries, wages, freelancer payments, bonuses, and benefits, as well...

Read more

5 Top Payroll Frustrations for SMBs

5 Top Frustrations SMBs Experience With Payroll According to a survey by the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB), 70% of small business owners feel payroll taxes are a significant to moderate burden, while 77% report income taxes as an additional burden. Added to this, about 54% of businesses think their payroll processes can be improved in some way. Here...

Read more

Gusto: A Payroll Software Turned ‘People Platform’?

Gusto Payroll Service launched in 2012 as a standard payroll service. As they’ve grown and expanded their services through their own systems, as well as through program partnerships, they’ve become much more. They’re now one of the leading payroll software services in the US, processing billions of dollars of payroll each year, and providing a full-service system for you and...

Read more

How Can the Best Payroll Software add Value to Your Company?

Gone are the days of using a calculator and signing an employee’s paychecks. Working in Finances or human resources, you need to track employees’ hours, wages, and deductions. This is just the basic information that is needed for payroll. When you have multiple employees, this becomes harder to track manually, and adding the best payroll software to your company can...

Read more